In their comprehensive study, "Hand the Shame Back," Dr Hannagh Mc Ginley and Dr Deirdre McGillicuddy shed light on the significant challenges faced by the Irish Traveller community in navigating the Irish educational system.
This research highlights the deeply entrenched barriers that affect access, retention and progression in further and higher education. However, it also provides a blueprint for potential solutions aimed at fostering success within the Traveller student population.
The challenges
- Discrimination and isolation in education
One of the most significant challenges Traveller students face is systemic discrimination and racism. From the early days of primary education, many are subjected to exclusion and isolation. Segregation into ‘special classes,’ often framed as necessary additional support, undermines the educational development of Traveller students and reinforces feelings of inferiority.
The study reveals that even in higher education, Travellers encounter racism and microaggressions from peers and educators alike. Such experiences create a toxic environment that hinders the retention and success of Traveller students, furthering the cycle of disengagement and early school leaving.
- Financial barriers and lack of support
Financial instability is another major hurdle for Travellers aspiring to progress in education. Many face compounded financial burdens due to family responsibilities, which make it difficult to remain in school or progress to higher levels of education. While schemes such as the SUSI, Ireland’s national awarding authority for further and higher education grants, provide some relief, they are often inadequate, especially for Traveller students who require additional support.
The lack of intergenerational educational capital within the community further exacerbates this issue. Traveller students frequently come from families where higher education was not an option, leaving them with little guidance or support in navigating the complexities of educational institutions.
- Cultural disconnect and absence in the curriculum
Traveller students often feel disconnected from the curriculum which largely ignores their culture, history and contributions to society. This absence reinforces the perception that education is not for them, contributing to a lack of motivation and engagement.
The solutions
- Cultural sensitivity training for educators
Educators play a vital role in shaping the educational experience for all students. Continuous professional development focused on cultural sensitivity and anti-racism training can help dismantle biases that perpetuate exclusion.
A concerted effort is needed to equip educators with the knowledge and tools to better understand the cultural background of Traveller students and foster a more inclusive environment.
- Wraparound supports for Traveller students
Retaining Traveller students in education requires holistic support that goes beyond financial aid. Academic mentoring, emotional support and career guidance tailored to the specific needs of Traveller students will help ensure their success. Programs like HEAR (Higher Education Access Route, an HE admissions scheme for Leaving Certificate students under 23 whose economic or social background are underrepresented in HE) and DARE (Disability Access Route to Education, a third level alternative admissions scheme for school-leavers under the age of 23 whose disabilities have had a negative impact on their second level education) should be promoted and simplified to ensure that Traveller students can easily access them.
Additionally, institutions must consider the unique challenges faced by Traveller students with families, providing flexible learning options and childcare support to enable them to balance education and family life.
- Incorporating Traveller culture into the curriculum
One of the key solutions to fostering a sense of belonging among Traveller students is ensuring that their history and culture are recognised within the national curriculum. Including Traveller contributions to Irish society would validate their identity and provide non-Traveller students with a more comprehensive understanding of Ireland’s cultural diversity.
The ongoing work surrounding the Traveller Culture and History in Education Bill is a promising development that could help redress the absence of Traveller representation in the classroom. Such changes would help make education more relevant and engaging for Traveller students, increasing retention and progression rates.
- Mentorship and role models from the Traveller community
Mentorship is a critical factor in the success of Traveller students. The presence of Traveller role models who have navigated higher education offers a tangible source of inspiration and guidance. These mentors not only provide practical support but also help bridge the gap for students who may feel disconnected from the traditional academic path.
Community-based mentorship programs can help ensure that Traveller students have access to the support and resources needed to succeed.
Highlighting student success in the Traveller community
Despite the challenges, there are numerous examples of success within the Traveller community. Programs like the Dormant Accounts Fund, which has provided financial aid for Traveller students, and initiatives such as PATH (Programme for Access to Higher Education), have helped increase Traveller participation in higher education. Under the Dormant Accounts Fund and PATH programme, a number of Irish institutions have received funding to support Traveller access and participation in higher education. These programs, combined with mentorship and access programs, have enabled some Traveller students to excel and complete their degrees, demonstrating the potential for success when appropriate supports are in place.
Moreover, the study highlights that having positive relationships with educators, particularly the concept of "one good teacher," have been transformative for many Traveller students. These relationships have been instrumental in keeping students engaged, motivated, and on track to success.
Traveller students face substantial challenges in accessing and succeeding in higher education, but with targeted interventions, these barriers can be overcome. By focusing on cultural sensitivity training for educators, expanding holistic support services and making the curriculum more inclusive, institutions can help ensure that Traveller students not only access higher education but also thrive in it.
Dr Hannagh Mc Ginley is an Assistant Professor in Education at MIC Thurles. Dr Deirdre McGillicuddy is an Assistant Professor in Education at University College Dublin. Their research focuses on improving access to education for marginalised and underrepresented groups.
Join our upcoming free webinar exploring using the Framework for Student Access, Retention, Attainment and Progression.